Tank Balance Achieved?

[Lumadurin]

IBut if you put all 3 tanks on a dummy tanks does more damage than the other 2.

Dummies don't have mechanics that can interrupt your rotations.

The only thing that WAR leads in currently is that it has arguably the best personal cooldown spread of the three tanks.

• 20% mitigation on a 90s CD. (Rampart - Universal)
• 20% more healing on a 120s CD. (Convalescence - Universal)
• 20% max HP on a 120s CD. (Thrill of Battle)
• 30% mitigation + 50 potency retaliation on 120s CD (Vengance)
• 20% physical mitigation on 90s CD (Raw Intuition - goes extremely well with Awareness)
• "Panic Button" (Holmgang) on 180s CD, so it can be used more than once per fight.

But that doesn't matter when you won't be MT-ing outside of normal content currently anyways (unless your healers don't mind you entering DPS stance).

[FallenShadows]

Dummies don't have mechanics that can interrupt your rotations.

The only thing that WAR leads in currently is that it has arguably the best personal cooldown spread of the three tanks.

• 20% mitigation on a 90s CD. (Rampart - Universal)
• 20% more healing on a 120s CD. (Convalescence - Universal)
• 20% max HP on a 120s CD. (Thrill of Battle)
• 30% mitigation + 50 potency retaliation on 120s CD (Vengance)
• 20% physical mitigation on 90s CD (Raw Intuition - goes extremely well with Awareness)
• "Panic Button" (Holmgang) on 180s CD, so it can be used more than once per fight.

But that doesn't matter when you won't be MT-ing outside of normal content currently anyways (unless your healers don't mind you entering DPS stance).

Dont forget 20% mitigation on 50 gauge cost possible upkeep of up to 70% if you forego any and all dreams of doing real damage for whatever purpose.