I don't know how you scholar mains do it.

[KDSilver]

I really don't want to be rude but...

Even if I personnaly quit Scholar because I found it unfun now and switch to WHM instead and even if I think Scholar should need to be fixed on some points just like adlo mp cost, fey union, excog, chain strategem, its healing potency and so on...

What you are writing here suggest that you had a bad healing rotation too.
Saying the fairy became useless is exagerated. She had a nerf on embrace and fey illumination because of Fey union, yes but...
You can still Rouse her, use eye for an eye, take largess as cross abilites, use fey illumination that is now 10% indeed but still a heal boost.
Physick isn't a heal to be taken alone cause you'll always have your fairy embrace.

Yes, there are crappy tanks that pull all the dungeon without CD and it's their fault.
But then again, while I think scholar need indeed some fixes, you're exagerating imo.
You still have Dissipation as an emergency AF need, you don't spam adloquium until running dry of mp...
You adlo the tank, you lustrate, then you psysick + rouse the fairy, you eventually largess + adloquium then lustrate, fey illumination, swifcast + emergency tactics...

In any case, ranting about scholar for sad dungeons experience isn't a thing when you might performing badly as well.
Also, the chocobo example is ridiculous. Keep in mind that even if scholar raw healing is still lower than the other, the fairy is still a free healing through time.

So please, I understand Scholar's sadness in general, I have the same feeling for this class I loved so much, but try to be at least a little more objective when complaining about problems he truly has.
Thank you.