So how was your Tanking experience so far?

[Pyrali]

Bad.

WAR is not fun anymore. SE needs to either put VIT back in our Damage Modifiers (For both the purpose of our DPS, and for helping us generate Enmity as Damage is a factor in that) or let us equip STR accessories.

I put on my old 270 slaying accessories again and my Attack Power went up by over 300 points. I've been having issues holding aggro in a lot of dungeons--even in Tank stance, yes, before you jump on me. Why? The damage disparity between me, and the people I'm fighting for Aggro with.

Taking VIT out of damage calculations was the sneakiest, but most devastating nerf they pulled on all tanks, not just WAR. They've made my job frustrating and completely sucked the joy out of it. I'm really upset.

[Shurrikhan]

I'm actually really happy with PLD right now. I'm still outdpsing the occasional caster in high-movement boss fights, but more importantly I have a second raid defensive and can self-heal for 23k crits at a mere i300, allowing my AST to spam Gravity once I'm out of TP while I spam heals (for plentiful threat, I may add).

...I don't, however, wish to discuss DRK or WAR at this time, because they're not yet at 70 and I'm not sure I have the willpower to take them there (especially DRK) in their current state.

While enmity seems to be a slightly larger concern than before, it isn't too bad on PLD. I can't necessarily say the same for WAR or DRK.

[Tankstuff]

the change from vit to str and locking us out of str accessories should be our biggest concern right now for all tanks we need to come together and get this fixed assp because the disparity is only going to increase as ilvl increases. i can stomach the war nerfs for now and would rather have this be the number one priority for the devs

[aqskerorokero]

I notice a common thing in the tanking community, who is more turtle style is happy with all 3 tanks, eventually a good tank should have all 3 and actually use them all. But who is "blue icon dps" has always things to complain on all 3 tanks.

[Alpha087]

Struggling to hold enmity in level 70 experts. I've been playing PLD since ARR and DRK since HW launch. Never had a problem with holding enmity in end-game dungeons until now. I don't like it at all and I really hope they change the way enmity is generated so I can actually use some of these other buttons they've given me.

Pretty much sums up my experience with tanking thus far, especially in level 70 content.

[Kumori_Kumo]

I notice a common thing in the tanking community, who is more turtle style is happy with all 3 tanks, eventually a good tank should have all 3 and actually use them all. But who is "blue icon dps" has always things to complain on all 3 tanks.

I play mega-defensively and I'm still really unsatisfied with how WAR plays. I feel a lot squishier, don't do as much damage AND it's really clunky.

[Mekhana]

DRK got all fun sucked out by a hull breach vacuum into outer space and is mostly unrewarding for the chore it is to play it now