Quote Originally Posted by alex4815162342 View Post
Skill or luck ?
Well, I really don't think a single OGCD will determine if you are good or bad, regardless of luck.
I mean, its not like all the other MNK attacks do -1 damage and only Forbidden Chakra does 5 millions.

Luck was already there ever since Crit has been a factor. And MNK had never been the only one affected by it.

Quote Originally Posted by Brill_ View Post
The stun on one ilm punch requires you to be in the right stance at the right time.

Considering how many 80% hasty touches I've had fail when crafting, I have my doubts that Chakra would fire like a machine gun at 30% chance.

Our level 70 quest better gives the title "The Riddler"
1+ for The Riddler, I would like that title.
Well, for One Ilm Punch, it says that "Stun is impervious to nullifying effects", so maybe you can stun your target even if they are immune to normal stuns. That would make sense.
80% chance of success still has a 20% chance of failure that can happen... I've failed crafts at 98% chance, and HQed items with 1% chance to do so.

With that 30% chance, along with 1 ranged, 2 tanks and 1 melee companion, you get a 30%x4 chance per weaponskill every 2~2.5 seconds for 15 seconds. Some are bound to happen.

As a side note, MNK will hate casters.