Quote Originally Posted by Ibi View Post
I think the idea is that Hydaelyn heard their prayers but couldn't do anything to save the First, because her direct influence is limited to the Source; she needed to create an emissary, in the form of the Word, that could go to the First and take in the Light.
I could understand that reasoning if Arbert hadn't specifically stated that they had done everything they had been told to do. The only explanation I can think of that justifies this reasoning is that, around the same time Hydaelen stopped talking to our WoL, she stopped giving them orders. However, still acting on the last instructions they were given, they continued to destroy Primals and The Ascians until none were left on The First. Arbert does voice his frustration that she is just now claiming to answer their prayers, but there still hasn't really been any good reason as to why Hydaelen stopped talking in the first place aside from "she was weak."

As for Minfilia having to stop Arbert's attack, all she did was merely raise her hand. She didn't block his attack; she forcefully made him stop moving. Then she explained that "As The Ascians must act out the will of their master, Zodiark, so must the recipients of the Mother's gift do her will also." I'm paraphrasing, but that's generally what she said. Basically, she admits that, as a Warrior of Light, that you have the only choices you have are to either 1) do what she says or 2) do nothing at all. You can't lash out at her because, as you see with Arbert, the Warrior of Light would be physically incapable of attacking her.

It's kind of like being tempered, but you're still in control 99% of the time. She just gets that 1% as a fail safe.