Patch 3.22, the Feast, and Jobs in PvP Revisited

[Petite]

By this logic sleep shouldn't be usable by WHM or BLM, or it should just root instead, because their counterparts aren't able to completely lock down their targets with 1 ability.

You're ignoring the main point of my argument. There should be an exception made only to Aetherflow mainly because it is crucial to SCH and SMN. The fact alone that MNK can remove that buff make SMN and SCH much less enticing to play in 4v4 solo/party for fear of facing off against Monks. Considering you reached Diamond as a MNK, you should know that already.

[Koltik]

You're ignoring the main point of my argument. There should be an exception made only to Aetherflow mainly because it is crucial to SCH and SMN. The fact alone that MNK can remove that buff make SMN and SCH much less enticing to play in 4v4 solo/party for fear of facing off against Monks. Considering you reached Diamond as a MNK, you should know that already.

I have an even better w/l on ninja than I do monk, so maybe Ninja's are the true class that need a nerf?

[Petite]

I have an even better w/l on ninja than I do monk, so maybe Ninja's are the true class that need a nerf?

Nice try.

Anyway I think at this point all melees are close in terms of usefulness and balance. It's just that MNK directly and utterly countering two Jobs only because they can remove Aetherflow is too much in my opinion.