Pretty much agree with every point stated so far, especially Cynric's last comment. To be sure...don't wanna come off like this is a 'lets hate all brds/blms vent. In the right hands (Dani Ross/ Bananajuice for example) the jobs are respectable enough. It just feels like with the jobs mechanics for the effort involved, at BEST..they just break even. In both cases, IF the job is ignored..they can do great things.But if focused? smn vs blm: a focused smn can still unload heavily while on the run, blm, next to none. mch vs brd..same thing....mch can 'full'burst on the fly, + heavy targets (which im starting to find surprisingly tactical lol) and still retain a shread of decency against closers if that turrent is out. Brd...cant fully burst while moving, suffers from somewhat larger cds for its binds/ pushbacks.
Kinda still out for lunch regarding tanks. Just due to previous experiences in WD, when tanks decide to follow their second calling of ' i r a dps tew dammit!' and go after other targets aside from healer pestering...id rather have a war over a pld or drk. If plds actually doing his 'job' (ya ya..politically incorrect word there) and riding the healer all the way back to his innroom, maybe pld. Otherwise war. Sure there are some skilled drks who are doing great things but havent seen anything tideworthy in general yet for them so D:
Meleewise...even though i be drg, gonna have to put my pride aside and give mnk the vote 100% for 1 inch punch ><; Just being able to strip the clothes.err..buffs off that cute lil lala smn and be able to appreciate her inner beauty more without all the barriers to get in the way..ooo lala~ same thing for healers. As for nins..well..purely so as not to offend anyone, i'll just pretend its ballista again, I ate some sushi..and all the shadows are down. ;o Unlike the brd vs smn thing though...nin can play better than mnk and drg in contribution for the team so with them, guess it just depends 101% on the user's style. ...*coughbutgenerallyninsuxj/kcough*
Healer department? With a few freak exceptions (like a big fat huggable snowman roe whm who shall forever remain nameless) quit being lazy and go lvl ast lol ..j/k j/k. Seriously, the jobs built for pvp like no other. As Dimitri said..theyre the one job 'usually' that can carry its own weight for extended time w/o breaking under pressure. As a melee..it gets downright tiring seeing 0, 0, 0, hit after hit on your target because that ast is doing his thing.