The fairy deal (thoughts about future SCH fairy possibilities, incl. a third one)

[Lyrica_Ashtine]

"What do we think"
Not this shit again

[Midaja]

"What do we think"
Not this shit again

As this seems to be your standard post in all of the threads you linked, I guess you didn't read what I wrote and / or didn't think about it.

1st of all its not only a "give us a new fairy!"-, but also a "rebalance the player / fairy weight"-thread, combined with a rather well-thought concept, in comparison to any of the threads you just linked.

If we let Helios aside, even the change with Embrace / Punishment and Spiritual Bonding would have a rather large impact, since Selene would completely loose the ability to heal, while the DPS you gain as a Scholar through Eos taking over much of the healing, should (numbers would have to be tweaked accordingly) not be as much as you gain from Selene.

So if you want to deal max DPS you would have to always be ready to switch back to healing, but you would do more damage when actually healing.
On the other side Eos would boost your healing greatly and still allow for you to focus on DPS with the actual fairy heal-output (on the tank at least), but it will just be less DPS than with Selene.

So thinking "Not this shit again" is, in my oppinion, a bit narrow-minded in this case, because... Well... It's not really the same shit