Why so much hate for job/class ideas?

[AlphaSonic]

The irony here kills me.

Thematic wise I love Astrologian (and the animations I love all of them). But the skill repertoire... It's just a SCH/WHM rehash with some cards and CD's that affect cards. At least when I see some job design posted by users, they don't try to be a wannabe of an ingame class with a different weapon. Of course i'm not demanding that every single ability is different from the other healers, I understand that it needs to have some base compared to other healers. But the part that defines Astro are Cards (Which are underwhelming but I love the concept) and Aspects (Which I hate because they are just WHM/SCH underpowered versions of heals with a thematic that it already exists with SCH).