WAR love is out of hand. Twelve forbid the other Tanks stand out in any way.

[Abomination713]

I main a PLD. Always have and always will. I know the PLD is the weakest tank and has the worst aoe dps of any of the tanks at the moment, but I still them it. The WAR has always been more versitile when it comes to MT or OT and has had skills to support both and that's what seperates it from the Def heavy PLD. However, I just recently learned that has pretty much destroyed some of the things that made PLD special.

The WAR has a DPS stance called Deliverance that gives them 5% increased base damage and can gain 10% increase to crit hit rate with access to a 500 potency attack when full. Did the WAR really need more damage increase at this point? They can already increase their DPS with a buff and it was always a great dps when wearing slaying accessories.

The PLD now has a skill called Clemency that cures for 1200 potency. It takes 40-45% of our total MP to cast, has a 3 second cast timer, and when used to heal others, 50% of the heal comes back to us. Pretty neat skill, but can't be used quick and only useful if the healer dies or by yourself. However, SE gave the WAR a better self heal. Are you fucking shitting me? It's called Equilibrium. It has no cast time, cures 1200 potency with in Defiance and gives 200 TP while in Deliverance, and is off the CGD. Is this a giant joke by SE? Can the other tanks not have anything to call their own? At this point I'm worried SE will give the WAR's a Hallowed Ground of their own.

Why is SE doing this? Why are they giving so much love and versatility to one tank other the others? When are they going to show the PLD some love? Am I just crazy to think this is complete bull?

[Freyyy]

[Abomination713]

This has nothing to do with the topic at hand. I don't have a problem holding my own. This is about the WAR getting abilities that they shouldn't be getting. PLD is the only one that should get a heal. Our cross class is CNJ for crying out loud. Self heals make zero sense for WAR since there's nothing that would even suggest they could heal at all.

[ManaKing]

This has nothing to do with the topic at hand. I don\\\\'t have a problem holding my own. This is about the WAR getting abilities that they shouldn\\\\'t be. PLD is the only one that should get a heal. Our cross class is CNJ for crying out loud. Self heals make zero sense for WAR since there\\\\'s nothing that would even suggest they could heal at all.

Warriors are berserkers. That would suggest they can self heal or fight through pain. Sounds like you are stuck on your shinning knight motif and ignored others.

PLD is now the MT that mitigates physical damage the best. If that\\'s not optimal for the fight, then you\\'re not optimal for the fight. You still have Hallowed Ground, which is the best mitigation in the game when used properly.

WAR specializes as an OT and you generally always want one for slashing debuff unless you have a NIN to increase party DPS.

You aren\\'t the best tank anymore. It\\'s not 2.0. Raid groups don\\'t have 2 PLDs for both tank slots. Other jobs are relevant. Things cost more than they used too!

[Dererk]

tell this to all the Bards who are getting out DPSD by wars.

[repoe]

Am I just crazy to think this is complete bull?

[Disc]

WAR has always had crit bonus. The changes made them do more damage out of tank stance & less damage in tank stance.(which had the crit bonus) Their self heal is only a self heal, which limits what they can do with it compared to PLD. PLD casting on another player also results in an effective 50% potency boost, or 1800 potency. Clemency is very good used in A4, and I'm thinking it may actually be a nice life saver in addition to Sheltron after getting rocked by Jagd Doll + Boomcannon on DRK, which does damage based on how low your HP is. Keep in mind WAR also have a 60 second cool down on it.

SE is pushing WAR further into the OT slot with these new abilities. You wouldn't care if you didn't have to compete with DRK for the MT slot.

[Abomination713]

PLD casting on another player also results in an effective 50% potency boost, or 1800 potency..

It doesn't do 1800 potency for healing a partner. We get 50% of the HP healed on partners back to us as a bonus for healing someone else.

[Disc]

It doesn't do 1800 potency for healing a partner. We get 50% of the HP healed on partners back to us as a bonus for healing someone else.

What's 50% of 1200? 600. If you heal somebody for 1200 potency & receive half that healing back, you have effectively healed 1800 total potency.

[Abomination713]

What's 50% of 1200? 600. If you heal somebody for 1200 potency & receive half that healing back, you have effectively healed 1800 total potency.

It only gives 50% of what we managed to heal on the person so that doesn't always mean we will get 600 back. It is not 1800 potency since it isn't for one person.

EDIT:I was wrong on this. You do get the full 600 potency back. When I was using it I sometimes didn't see the return heal and sometimes I did.