o.O Overkill on the crafting Dumb down?

[darkstarpoet1]

You think only some of it will be taken out due to materia? If you fail a 5th materia attachment you just lost 5 materia plus the gear, that's 6 pieces of gear effectively. Now consider people will be doing this for all types of equipment (all armor slots + accessories + weapons). Tons of gear will be taken out of the system every day simply by conversion and failed attachment.

People may rank up on the "easiest" gear to make but they will likely start to make and sell the best gear for materia and the best gear to slot materia into.

do you think you will be able to level up a peice of gear to be 100% spiritbound as fast as i can make one finished item? if i make 5-6 for every 1 you buy and get bound then it is not going to assist the economy. it will put multiple times the amount of product and you will not be able level them fast enough to be able to be converted.

just like i said, yes, instead of having one velveteen robe red you may have 2-3 of them, but if people are grinding on that item and there's thousands of them being made it will still be the same thing. i do the same thing grinding parts. i put a stack of whatever i am grinding into the wards and let them sell, but the rest go to the npc. do you think people are going to make an alt just to hold their 300 robes? if so what do they do with the 300 of their next grind item?

[TheVedis]

do you think you will be able to level up a peice of gear to be 100% spiritbound as fast as i can make one finished item? if i make 5-6 for every 1 you buy and get bound then it is not going to assist the economy. it will put multiple times the amount of product and you will not be able level them fast enough to be able to be converted.

just like i said, yes, instead of having one velveteen robe red you may have 2-3 of them, but if people are grinding on that item and there's thousands of them being made it will still be the same thing. i do the same thing grinding parts. i put a stack of whatever i am grinding into the wards and let them sell, but the rest go to the npc. do you think people are going to make an alt just to hold their 300 robes? if so what do they do with the 300 of their next grind item?

its obvious people dont understand economy dark, might as well give up
tried to explain similar things to people earlier in this thread and they were totaly clueless thinking every item they made even if in the thousands would sell