are we considered members of the syndicate?

[Krylo]

Probably not, but frankly, that's because of our own stupidity. If we used our influence like we should, instead of being a pawn to anyone who needs our services, we could most definately have a seat in the Syndicate.

We don't really operate on the same level as the syndicate, and if we did we'd be useless and quickly lose our influence and standing.

Do you think Lolorito has time between business meetings, economic planning meetings, and politicking to go kill primals, stop a dragon war with his fists, or personally spearhead a Garlean counter-offensive?

No. No he does not.

We're heroes, not kingdom administrators or corporate CEOs. It's an entirely different skill set, and an entirely different sort of influence from the WoL.