Thoughts from a 60 AST & 60 WHM

[lordparanoia]

I play AST lvl 60 especially on nocturnal stance since I have a whm on my static. I don't have time to give you my feedback yet. I up my scholar to 60 (still 58 actually) because, personnally, I think without all the emergency heals from my scholar it will be too difficult (or even impossible) during savage raids for my static.

This is the point.
Some people just don't understand the importance of emergency heals during progression. When people make mistake, or even when the co-healer can't provide a sufficient amount of healing (for many reasons), AST will begin to have problems.
Of course, AST is perfect for dungeons and duty roulette, but I think that a SCH or WHM will just shine more then AST in Alexander (savage).