Cleric stance = Commendation

[tocsin]

When I was getting my Lancer to Lv.22 in Halatali, a scholar wanted to hasten the run so she was on cleric, healing on cleric too. The tank (main whitemage) did his best, but due lack of heals he KO'ed several times.. He would have died a lot more if the Black mage didn't heal!!! eventually we lost our tank because the scholar wanted to DPS.

Something in this story rings weirdly to me. Did the tank use any of his mitigation abilities? did the scholar summon his fairy while in cleric stance? if the fairy is summoned from normal stance, or even before the instance, the scholar shouldn't have had to heal through Halatali. I personally have done this run, and the fairy solo healed the entire thing without even requiring protect (my first two scholar cross classes are cleric and aero).

That might also have been a new, and unknowledgeable scholar. I have had multiple scholars first get their classes, look at all their +INT statted armor, and think that cleric stance gives them better heals than regular stance does.

[Kuwaitum]

Something in this story rings weirdly to me..

I am a Lv.50 Scholar and I did Halatali, I know the fairy is capable to heal.. but for some reason the heals were weak. I saw the fairy Embrace heals, I assume the scholar was manually giving commands to heal. more tahn 70% of heals were done by the BLM. She started healing better when another tank joined the duty.

[PetiteMalFleur]

did the scholar summon his fairy while in cleric stance?

Summoning in cleric stance doesn't affect the fairy. But yes, the story seems off to me too. I've done the entire dungeon with my fairy solo healing while I stay in clerics. Scholar could have stood out of range for the fairy to heal, or their gear was broken.