Dungeon Weapons, city weapons, HQ weapons OH MY!!!!

[Visch]

What is truly (HQ included) the best weapon for:

GLA - (tanking) Ul'dahn Scimitar (Don't see STR+2 doing anything and DEF+5 when the mob already attacks for 0... most of the time? HP Plz.) / (DD) Aeolian +3 (lol)
* Best Shield? - Vintage Kite Shield +3 (Batraal one is garbage compared to a +1 and Scutums are just silly because of the wield rate).

PUG - (tanking) Verdant Hora / (DD) Peiste Cesti +3 (If you need the Acc), Jade Horas +3 (If you don't).

MRD - (tanking) Canopus Bill / (DD) Barbarian's Bardiche +3 (Have fun getting that so Engraved +3 is good enough)

LNC - Champion's Lance +3 (Again, good luck on that, Banneret +3 is good enough and a lot easier)

ARC - Verdant or Crab bow +3.... This is what needs testing but I can't see any reason why Ul'dahn longbow is good at all 1 more attack then a crab bow +2? That is just silly any shouldn't even be considered.

CON (should they staff or wand/shield) - Nooo Idea. Depends on what you're doing. (Sleeping, nuking, healing.)
THM (*see CON) - Nooo Idea. Depends on what you're doing. (Sleeping, nuking, healing.)

[Cursive]

CON (should they staff or wand/shield) - Nooo Idea. Depends on what you're doing. (Sleeping, nuking, healing.)
THM (*see CON) - Nooo Idea. Depends on what you're doing. (Sleeping, nuking, healing.)

there is no reason for con and thm not to use a shield...aegis boon II is pretty broken atm. it increases your survivability of shit hits the fan.

[Raze]

GLA - (tanking) Ul'dahn Scimitar (Don't see STR+2 doing anything and DEF+5 when the mob already attacks for 0... most of the time? HP Plz.) / (DD) Aeolian +3 (lol)
* Best Shield? - Vintage Kite Shield +3 (Batraal one is garbage compared to a +1 and Scutums are just silly because of the wield rate).

Gotta agree with you (although some of those items are unreal on my server (Aeolian +3, kite +3).

One point, do you think that canopus shield will surpass Kite +1 when stats work?

(Plus I'm ARM so <3 canopus when I'm in a pinch)

[Visch]

Gotta agree with you (although some of those items are unreal on my server (Aeolian +3, kite +3).

One point, do you think that canopus shield will surpass Kite +1 when stats work?

(Plus I'm ARM so <3 canopus when I'm in a pinch)

No real way to tell... When they add "jobs" I would think soon after they would add AF similar to XI which will probably be better than most armor anyway. And maybe level cap to 60? Who knows.