R50 Weapons: Halberd vs Lance vs Guisarme

[Alcide]

Non-lance weapons are absolutely horrible against everything except bones and crabs. And even in a bone-heavy area like the second floor of DH, you are still better off using either a Banneret NQ/+1/+2/+3 or a Champion's. Banneret +1 is better than Champion's NQ.

I'm sorry but I fail to understand this, IMHO Lominsan's stats are much better than Champion's or Benneret's, why should I choose one of those two just because of the 100%piercing over the 40%piercing, 40%slashing, 20%blunt of the Lominsan?

(I'm not saying you're wrong, just trying trying to learn something :P)