Quote Originally Posted by Makado View Post
Best in slot is totally up to you.
No, it's not. Best in slot means the best item for that item slot for that class. There is really no arguing what is the best in slot. If item1 is worth 400 points and item2 is worth 430 points, item2 is the clear BiS. Even if the outcome is a tiny increase in DPS, it is still the superior option.

Does that mean you have to play that way? No, not necessarily. But don't try to change what BiS means.