First off, I'm well aware that it works. That isn't up to debate here, so please don't.

BUT. . .

If it takes 15 DPS to do what is easily a 5 man job, we have much bigger problems. And after careful scrutiny, I can safely say the All DPS in method really isn't any faster than having one alliance team get eaten and do their part from the inside. The key aspect is both having good DPS and EVERYONE doing their part when inside, of course.

It might be "foolproof" (now THAT is debatable), but that doesn't make it more effective at all.