I am all for some thinking outside the box. We don't really have to follow WoW's raid structure to the letter every tier.
Now, I don't know about just copying ideas straight from FFXI--I'd rather Yoshida's team come up with something brand new--but just using them as examples of what could be done is fine.

Quote Originally Posted by BlaiseArath View Post
Also, I'm not one to shy from discussion, I do only ask if you dislike, state why. Give me a reason why it would be bad for endgame variety in content, or why you think these wouldn't be good ways to put them in. Keeping in mind both Tome Grinding and "Coil" would still be options for everyone, these would just be added on top of those options.
Maybe I am merely embittered by the result of my own thread, but I wouldn't expect much of this on this forum :|.