PSA: NIN and WAR relations

[Kenji1134]

Yeah, although War does generally have strong ST hate generation, if they must maintain Path and Eye, well...
BB Combo = 150+200*3+280*5 = 2150 base.
SP Combo = 150+190+250 = 590 base.
SE Combo = 150+190+270 = 610 base.
And Buffs/Stance amount to x1.2 (Maim) x.75 (Defiance) x2 (Defiance) = 1.8x buff/stance mod.

So a rotation of SP-BB-BB, the standard tanking rotation, is 4890 in 9 gcds, so ~ 217/sec, x1.8 from buffs/Defiance is 391, and I'd say most wars have about a 1.4ish potency value around this gear level... I think? So thats 547 hate/sec, with SP-BB-BB. Meaning if someone is pushing 550 dps, they will outaggro the Warrior.

Now, SE-SP-BB, maintaining both, cause you ALWAYS want SP up when tanking, is 3350*1.1 in 9 gcds, or 413/sec x1.8 x1.4 potency value is... 376 hate/sec... That is a pretty big drop, thats 68% of the hate output of the SP-BB-BB rotation.

Then again, this is just "math".
Why not just have a 110 Ninja and a 110 Warrior have an aggro fight on a dummy? Both with, and without cooldowns. I imagine that with cooldowns, the Warrior will hold aggro for a while with SE-SP-BB, but eventually lose.
Though without CD's, and with the Warrior using SE-SP-BB, I am pretty sure the Ninja (or a Monk) will pull off within 30 seconds.