There is one thing that's not fair with this new system, that no one has brought up yet...

A couple of friends queued up in a party together, their first duty ever that day. No one had queued for anything at all. And for one reason or other, one of them timed out on the queue pop -- and they all got locked out. If it worked as it should, they might all have gotten one penalty (though I think it should just be the one timing out who should get it, but fair enough). Now they each got one penalty per person in the group, meaning three or four penalties each instead of just one -- I forget if they were three or four people queuing. And that cannot be "working as intended".

And yes, I know these people well enough to know they were telling the truth about not having any penalties since before.