Titan Tanking Nerfed Again!? ... WHY!? There is NO reason for this!

[Aelinau]

Savage Coil progression (extremely doubtful in this case) or 30VIT build for SCH in PvP.

Suppose so, i still think the hit to int on smner would hurt dps too much, but to each thier own

[Malric]

I'm not sure what you are doing wrong? Titan holds hate just fine when i duo pieste maps whm + smner(we even drag the adds to him so he grabs hate on them (chimera/turtle/ect) or alex maps smner + blm(both kindsof maps were done today)... i havent tanked dungeons with him this "week" but last week he did just fine tanking the tonberry dungeon. Also im not sure why the vit build..but you're losing alot of dps by gimping urself 30 int.

Because I like it?

I also play SCH and VIT is the only stat I've found to be really useful to both sides

I tank a LOT of dungeons with Titan
Best Copper HM run I've ever had was my SMN, a new SMN and a SCH after the tank bailed at like 2am a few days ago

As I often play both in the same day (dungeon que as SCH and solo as SMN) so 10k seals every time I switch isn't very worth it.

[Malric]

Suppose so, i still think the hit to int on smner would hurt dps too much, but to each thier own

It only hurts when you're trying to please a parser, in real play it's not that bad at all.
No one I play with uses them so it's never actually been an issue.
Never had anyone complain about my dps so...

The survivability is well worth it. I've survived a LOT of things that 1 hit other squishy.

(Yes for the record SCH in PvP is one contributing factor, I played SCH before SMN)

If SE meant for every character to only put max (insert primary stat here) there wouldn't really be a reason to have stat distribution.

Oh and 6.7k HP w/ dungeon buff (will probably break 7k soon) on a caster and 11.5k HP on Titan is enjoyable.

[Argyle_Darkheart]

Okay my titan can hold agro on a dummy too... and?

If you can't ascertain why a dummy test is relevant to this discussion, then I seriously doubt I'm the one with the problem here.

[Aelinau]

snip.

snip

i was not attacking.. i just didnt understand ur logic. If its for PVP i guess i can understand. PvE wise you are gimping yourself eitherway...i dont use parser nor do i agree with the drama that comes with them, i however know the importance of main stat that CAN help both sch and smner in a PvE setting rather then ohh my hp is high. In either case as i said each their own. Back to topic and onto what others were saying a dummy has "threat" like any other mob.. test are = to any lvl 50 regular mob.(thats to the lvl 50 dummies ofc)

[Sanguisio]

Titan's aggro production is based off you, just like Vit, so the more you gimp yourself the more you gimp titan.

Yes Titan cant build stupid aggro like War on the set off, but if you give titan egi a sec to generate some aggro with buffs + enkindle you shouldnt have a problem

[Exstal]

Because I like it?

I also play SCH and VIT is the only stat I've found to be really useful to both sides

In that case 15/15 MND/INT is vastly superior.

[Riepah]

In that case 15/15 MND/INT is vastly superior.

Not in PvP.

[Deelo]

Not in PvP.

Subjective.

[SeraviEdalborez]

Subjective.

Nothing beats 30VIT for SCH in PvP. Period.