Do NOT make the same mistake as FFXI.

[Physic]

Who said anything about dodging or running away? I said stun, not dodge. STUN. The rest is all positioning (within melee range.)

do WS still lock your position? Far as what i ve seen a decent amount of your dps change comes from doing WS and as often as possible now? so in a 20 minute fight if i hold back from doing my WS for 1 second out of every 10 seconds, in order to dodge aoe, wont my dps take a decent hit from cool downs? Is my dmg proportiolly higher than an archers for the dodging i have to do? or is it in fact lower even before i have to dodge?

How much utility am i adding to the fight? these are things SE needs to figure out for balancing classes properly.

also at the end of the day, my problem is maybe you can be superman, and dodge the aoe like a pro, but you still are doing less dmg than a class that is taking a lot less risk. Now even more than before since you can guage enimity more easily for DD.

Im not saying they should have no challenge, or no dodging, im saying they need to balance the fights, archers should have to be just as much as a super ninja to get away with doing good DPS or no one is going to take them. If for all the ninja tricks archer is still the safest, easiest and also largest DD then that is a balancing fail, and it isnt really your problem, its SE's problem.

[MeowyWowie]

do WS still lock your position? Far as what i ve seen a decent amount of your dps change comes from doing WS and as often as possible now? so in a 20 minute fight if i hold back from doing my WS for 1 second out of every 10 seconds, in order to dodge aoe, wont my dps take a decent hit from cool downs? Is my dmg proportiolly higher than an archers for the dodging i have to do? or is it in fact lower even before i have to dodge?

How much utility am i adding to the fight? these are things SE needs to figure out for balancing classes properly.

also at the end of the day, my problem is maybe you can be superman, and dodge the aoe like a pro, but you still are doing less dmg than a class that is taking a lot less risk. Now even more than before since you can guage enimity more easily for DD.

Im not saying they should have no challenge, or no dodging, im saying they need to balance the fights, archers should have to be just as much as a super ninja to get away with doing good DPS or no one is going to take them. If for all the ninja tricks archer is still the safest, easiest and also largest DD then that is a balancing fail, and it isnt really your problem, its SE's problem.

Again with the dodging... There's NO dodging involved at all.

You're doing the same exact shit that you be normally doing except you have to stand in the correct position to avoid things like cone attacks and time certain abilities.

You don't lose any DPS at all if done correctly.

[Physic]

Again with the dodging... There's NO dodging involved at all.

You're doing the same exact shit that you be normally doing except you have to stand in the correct position to avoid things like cone attacks and time certain abilities.

You don't lose any DPS at all if done correctly.

Ok, so you are saying you can use your WS in set rotation as melee without delaying in the cooldowns? because if you can then you can achieve your high dps as a DD, but if you have to delay for a second to go from 80 degrees to 140 degrees, or you have to save TP for an interupt skill, you are lowering your DPS, which would be fine, if Archers also have to lower thier dps.

However if you can do a rotation fine without wasting any cool down times, then the issue will just become the overall dps being higher on archer. And the fact you may have to work harder to do the same thing.