macros: bad for DPS?

[Illrayth]

woah, this turned into a slug fest.
i think everyone acknowledged quickly, including me in my post (although i should have said DPS Classes/Jobs, not necessarly DPS output), that the macro has less than optimal dps. no one is arguing that in any way shape or form. I also didn't say that having a DPS Rotation macro is the only way a DPS is going to use their abilities. Far from it. 95% of all my abilities used are optimaly used manually.
But a macro to take over on derp moments, movement phases where you've got lag and have to concentrate harder than normal, someone in the room throwing something at the back of your head (IRL distractions), etc.
God no, if you JUST use a macro, thats not smart. but having one to use in some situations is a good thing.
lazy low level dungeons where you dont want to out dps tanks who have poor threat management.macro dps with friends on a casual dungeon lets you type to your party members, crack some jokes, have some fun.

dosn't have to be 100% all the time "go go go" to maximum potential or your a bad player. your high horse wants a rest. get off him.

[Odett]

quote

There will never be a time where a macro will trump correct manual input when it comes to DPS. Part of the challenge and (subjective) fun is knowing how to get back on the horse after a derp moment.

For low level dungeons, I personally like to get them over with as fast as possible. As a tank, I think it's really fun competing with a good DPS because it adds more fun to a run, but if a tank finds it aggravating and is actually using their skills properly, I might target a different mob once I agro one. On the other hand, if it's a "haha riot blade" tank, and I explain to them how to tank better and they don't do it, then I won't have qualms about going all out because accommodating yourself to someone doing a poor job generally breeds bad players.

Some people like to go 100% all the time. They find it fun to test new things on monsters and trying to get the most damage they can, so there's really no high horse to dismount.