I need a honest opinion about the Atma drop rate......

[skaterger]

Haibel, I will state this one last time as I posted earlier, I am going to continue for the rest of the month until the 30th. Then I will disclose my entire data for the complete month so I can clearly show the entire process for completion. If you are unable to wait for that long....then I am sorry....

Bump, still waiting.

[Skinypupy]

I've got 11 of the 12 atmas so far, and have been tracking how many it took for each zone. I think I've been quite lucky, as my average for the 11 I have so far has been 34 FATEs/atma. The shortest was 5 (yay!) and the longest was 92 (ugh).

Now that I've said that, of course, my last one will probably take 300 FATES to get.

[Nero]

I've got 11 of the 12 atmas so far, and have been tracking how many it took for each zone. I think I've been quite lucky, as my average for the 11 I have so far has been 34 FATEs/atma. The shortest was 5 (yay!) and the longest was 92 (ugh).

Now that I've said that, of course, my last one will probably take 300 FATES to get.

Gogo get the last one!

I guess my average would be somewhat around 50ish Fates. I had some really fast ones where i got 1, switched zones and straight got the next one. Then i had some, which really took an assload of Fates. But yeah.. i lost track after i hit 3k Fates, before i was around 50 Fates average so i keep going with that. Currently at 76/120, so still a bit to go. ( yes, allready farming for ninja as well xD )

[Maero]

Same boat as you op, i have spent multiple hours every day since the update on atma.
Took me a month and a half for my Bard but has been almost 3 months for my blm and only have 6 stones.
Some of you stating Atma is not as bad as it seems, well let me guess you got your full weapon in a few days or a week?
Seriously people how to you figure it is not bad, it is evil rng
Also op check the stats on the soldiery weapon for your class as it may in fact be better then Animus/Novus and less of a pain to get
High Allagan is still the best weapon in game

[Nero]

Some of you stating Atma is not as bad as it seems, well let me guess you got your full weapon in a few days or a week?
Seriously people how to you figure it is not bad, it is evil rng

My first Set of 12 Atma took around 2-3 Weeks.

I don't know, some people seem to have really bad luck, while i know people who got their full Set within a day. What i find interesting tho, i got ALL of my currently 76 Atma's out of Fates i did stay in and finished with Gold. Even if it possible to get them even from Silver and bronze, not being near the Fate Area and even from Fail Fates, that did not happen to me once. I did that quite often, when a couple fates where up at the same time, tagged some and then finished one and the one i got the atma from, was never Silver, was never Bronze, was never a Fail one and was never being outside. May there is a higher chance with Gold? Kind of like you get more mantles from Odin with Gold.

[Kaze3434]

it is now the day of truth.

[Cid_Grim]

It is now July... Still waiting patiently

[Hammerfist]

Personally I suggested every time you beat a fate in a certain area, the droprate of an atma in that area increases by 0.5% and the increase stays until you switch areas or haven't done any fates in the zone for an x amount of time. It would guarantee an atma drop about 30-40 fates in for the unluckiest of people.

This should really be implemented as soon as possible since in this way the atma quest would have at least some kind of progress: for the time being, doing endless fates in order to drop atmas and dealing with the RNG of this game in general just feels like a complete waste of time and it's one of the reasons why me and many other people stopped renewing the subscription.

[baopee]

#1-#11 - average 3 hours per atma

#12 - over 24 hours "archer"

[Nero]

It is now July... Still waiting patiently

OP is complaining in other Thread about almost everything. xD Looks more like a Troll to me, or someone who get paid by Blizzard for talking crap.