100% High Quality Two Star Rotation: No Food, NQ Materials, No RNG

[scarebearz]

It's not part of my rotation but it's very relevant, as melding the Craftsmanship means I don't have to use it. Since Waste Not II is a very inefficient use of CP by comparison you would hope any 'decent' crafter was using MM2...

I'm not aware of any crafter that uses MM2 for 2 star crafts, if you read my macro you would see it uses WN.

This is a very debatable point. How many three star synths do people actually make? I personally make far more two star synths (on Culinarian in particular).... without your proposed melds.

I craft more 3 star than 2 star, I don't cook as I don't consider the rewards (gil) to be worth my time, I buy raid food. That said, my Cul is 3 star ready, but no idea why I bothered xD The last point was not melds I propose at all, I'm happy using the minimum (3 star req's) craft/control and maxed CP. You and the previous person were talking about "max melds" and I said what you would need to meld to hit "397" craft while max-melding the other stat's.

The one point is not a big deal but price wise the materia level is.

I was basing a lot of my posts on the fact you said "397" was needed, 396 is a fair bit more affordable.

Then you're mistaken. The HQ rate on this rotation if you watch for the condition on Byregot's is 100%. Even with Poor on the Advanced Touch it reaches 100%. You should really give somebody's rotation a solid, thorough workthrough before you do your best to declare it's no good or false.

You are wrong imo, I have tested it (read above). I'm not saying you rotation is bad at all, it's decent, if you have the gear for it. But, it's not "100%", thought it's close enough for me personally.

I would suggest experimenting some more with this because if I get Poor on the Advanced Touch, with less Control than you, it is still reaching 100% quality 100% of the time.

It was a test, so I did it with the exact control you specify (375).

Often you'll still get 100% due to good on other Touch skills, but if those are normal, you'll be left with less than 100% if you get Poor on the AT.