No reward for catching all fish

[Alukah]

Well, I don't know if there's more than 160 fishes or not but...



I think this counts.

[Felis]

Well, I don't know if there's more than 160 fishes or not but...



I think this counts.

225 fishes
9 pages in the fish log, 25 fishes each page

[Bluevann]

225 fishes
9 pages in the fish log, 25 fishes each page

This.

The issue with what you're asking is that it would require SE to stop adding new fish and pages to the log. What if you achieved the "catch them all" achievement, got the reward, and then new fish were added? Would you lose your prize and have to get it back? Would you keep it? And then why not to demand a NEW "catch them all" prize?

If you're asking for more "catch X types of fish" achievements, I agree. But the "catch them all" achievement just can't work.

[Vahlnir]

This.

The issue with what you're asking is that it would require SE to stop adding new fish and pages to the log. What if you achieved the "catch them all" achievement, got the reward, and then new fish were added? Would you lose your prize and have to get it back? Would you keep it? And then why not to demand a NEW "catch them all" prize?

If you're asking for more "catch X types of fish" achievements, I agree. But the "catch them all" achievement just can't work.

I think it'd be feasible if you would be able to keep the achievement as well as the reward, but those who haven't done it would simply have more to catch toward the achieve when new fish are added. At the same time you could continue filling up your fishing log though. It's 100% workable but the results would certainly vary on what SE feels would be best.

[Myrhn]

The issue with what you're asking is that it would require SE to stop adding new fish and pages to the log. What if you achieved the "catch them all" achievement, got the reward, and then new fish were added? Would you lose your prize and have to get it back? Would you keep it? And then why not to demand a NEW "catch them all" prize?

If you're asking for more "catch X types of fish" achievements, I agree. But the "catch them all" achievement just can't work.

I understand what i meant by all was all that we have now, 225 fish or for the 37 (I think) big fish with a tittle or or glamour item/minion. The Master's Fish ring is nice but is something that every DoW/DoM/DoH/DoL gets. I was aiming more to the Big Fish that was added later than beside the archivement there is nothing more to it.

[Alistaire]

Well, I don't know if there's more than 160 fishes or not but...



I think this counts.

Oh let's not get started on the GP ring for the job that doesn't use GP.