Question on Scholar's pet

[Alistaire]

Oh I have nothing against theorycrafting. In fact I like to look up and learn new things, otherwise I wouldn't bother ever visiting this forum.

But there is an inherit amount of randomness involved because you can do the best you can to perfect your own strategies, your own way of handling your class, but you can't account for other people, and in the end, that will always affect your ability to play your class too.

No, I didn't mean to make it sound like you should throw your arms up in the air and go "Hmm, well, I'm just gonna roll with Eos today cause everything is a toss up!" But at the same time planning, strategy and skill only take you so far, not the entire way.

Exactly, just like the way I said "if you're overgeared for the event go Selene", that "overgeared" is a judgement call based not only on myself but the whole party, and there's been times I've switched to Eos after a wipe, either because people are taking more damage than they should, and in some cases in T5 where sometimes in the early phases more speed is more of a liability than a benefit.

[alhandra]

Fey Illumination every 2 minutes is not comparable imo to constant uptime of Fey Glow/Fey Light (since your party will always have at least 1 tank and 1 healer and 95% of the time 2 tanks and 2 healers someone will always benefit).

you clearly dont understand the usefulness of fey illum.

i use it to buff my fairy heals to allow me to DPS constantly in dungeons. by keeping up stoneskin(not affected by stance) and by rotating fey illum, rouse + dawn , virus and eye i can effectively allow my fairy to solo heal every encounter in the game up to ex primals without ever having to leave cleric stance(tho occasionally i may throw out a lustrate here or there, i dont have to drop stance for that). the dps i generate in cleric stance FAAAR exceeds any benefit to using selene instead

eos will always be the superior fairy unless selene gets a major overhaul

[ZaxLavayi]

you clearly dont understand the usefulness of fey illum.

i use it to buff my fairy heals to allow me to DPS constantly in dungeons. by keeping up stoneskin(not affected by stance) and by rotating fey illum, rouse + dawn , virus and eye i can effectively allow my fairy to solo heal every encounter in the game up to ex primals without ever having to leave cleric stance(tho occasionally i may throw out a lustrate here or there, i dont have to drop stance for that). the dps i generate in cleric stance FAAAR exceeds any benefit to using selene instead

eos will always be the superior fairy unless selene gets a major overhaul

You can do the same with Selene!

[alhandra]

You can do the same with Selene!

even in the expert dungeons? or on big pulls? it sounds a bit risky to me.

what if the tank decides to pull big? what if the dps decide to stand in bad stuff? with selene out you would most likely be dropping stance to help her out, especially without any group regen spell

[givemeraptors]

even in the expert dungeons? or on big pulls? it sounds a bit risky to me.

what if the tank decides to pull big? what if the dps decide to stand in bad stuff? with selene out you would most likely be dropping stance to help her out, especially without any group regen spell

Stance dancing isn't hard. Also, you will naturally have downtime once all your DoTs are applied. Ruin is filler on a SMN, on a SCH it's what you cast when you have literally nothing else to do.
Apply all DoTs, Bane --> SC --> Shadowflare etc etc. I can do it all with Selene. Maybe if you wanted to DPS while doing the most intense version of Bray SR you'd need Eos. Otherwise Selene all the way...

Even Titan Extreme can be easily healed with Selene.

[Exstal]

I can't justify Selene. The buffs aren't strong enough. Maybe if they bring it up to 40~50% then I'll take a second look.

Eos is king

[Sanguisio]

Selene can solo heal everything but ex primals and coil
on big pulls like 7+ mobs i'd suggest shielding as much as you can prior to pull, having lustrates ready, rouse the fey and dps with others until down to last lustrate.

[Sen_Terrechant]

I can't justify Selene. The buffs aren't strong enough. Maybe if they bring it up to 40~50% then I'll take a second look.

Eos is king

Someone hasnt been in T8 or 9

[Cynfael]

I can't justify Selene. The buffs aren't strong enough.

This is exactly my issue with Selene.

I agree that if Eos is completely superfluous in that if you have no use for the +healing, HoT, or magic defense AoEs, then Selene is obviously better. Unfortunately, even in that case, she's not better by very much at all since her effect on actual casting speed is extremely minimal and has a 50% uptime for either type.

It's difficult to love Selene when Eos provides more tangible benefits, even if her two buffing actions are more situational due to their limited uptime. It'd be nice to have a reason to use Selene besides her being the non-overhealing option for parties that don't need anything from Eos or for very specific skin-of-your-teeth DPS races where shaving ~0.14 seconds off of a cast actually can make the difference.

[Sanguisio]

Ok this is some napkin maths might be wrong but meh, btw the times were taking from a previous casting/spell speed analysis.
But the 30% buff selene provides is effective, even more so when you dont need Eos.
-30% on a base BLM spell speed 341 will provide a total casting reduction of .54secs which brings Fire I to 1.96 cast.

Lets take a 30 second period of uninterrupted casting -
Without buff 12 casts will = 1800 potency
With buff 15 casts = 2250
that's a 450 potency boost lets say 2 Blms 900 potency boost + the affect on others. Please note that is a boost over 30 secs, when considering the whole fight it would be a significant boost.

There is no reason not to use Selene when Eos isnt specifically required.