Vote Kick - HUGE Flaw. Needs an instant fix.

[Fervid]

If he's meeting the item level for the dungeon upon entering, then you really have no right to kick him, especially if he's participating. If he changed his gear (thus lowering his ilvl) after joining, then sure, a kick is justified.

Not to get too far off topic, because I agree, if someone is kicked they should not be able to rejoin the same instanced ID. However it sounds like CT has some other issues on top of that. iLvl requirements and/or being allowed to change gear (that drops iLvl below the requirement) after joining.

[Barboron]

If he's meeting the item level for the dungeon upon entering, then you really have no right to kick him, especially if he's participating. If he changed his gear (thus lowering his ilvl) after joining, then sure, a kick is justified.

Not to get too far off topic, because I agree, if someone is kicked they should not be able to rejoin the same instanced ID. However is sounds like CT has some other issues on top of that. iLvl requirements and/or being allowed to change gear (that drops iLvl below the requirement) after joining.

Well, unfortunately with the idea of not allowing someone to rejoin an instance it's kind of unfair to lock someone out of content for not doing anything wrong IF the kick is unjustified. Much like in this situation. Why should I be locked out of their CT run because him and his five other FC members decided to kick me because they followed his orders to kick me? At the same time however, you can get abusive players who deserve a kick. It's a lot of work to make a system to cater to all that and it's definitely something that we won't be given which is also unfortunate.

With regards to the ilvl, everything I had equipped was exactly what I had on when I queued. Should I have lowered my ilvl, especially removing items which would decrease my DPS, it goes back to slowing down my own progress so it's not something I wanted to do for myself either. Also, once again, have a like!

[Fervid]

Well, unfortunately with the idea of not allowing someone to rejoin an instance it's kind of unfair to lock someone out of content for not doing anything wrong IF the kick is unjustified.

If the kicking is unjustified, then I would report them for it. Allowing someone to join the same instance they were kicked from totally nullifies the kicking feature.

I agree, if I was kicked for an unfair reason, I would be upset too. But there does need to be a kicking feature, the positives outweigh the negatives.

There will always be people abusing features of the game, you can't blame SE for that.

[Barboron]

If the kicking is unjustified, then I would report them for it.

There's the issue, I contacted the GMs when it happened, explained the situation was purely down to my gear. Got a reply saying they couldn't do anything because I had to discuss it with the party leader. Replied saying it was a DF and finally, I got the most conclusive response of all...the GMs are no longer taking action against vote kick abuse. It's what I have been told from the GM him/herself.

This sound like your FC was looking for a speedrun and the other tank was new ie the gear and was watching cutscenes ie standing at the boss gate. Another clear violation of kick feature and the tos.

I wasn't new, I knew all the mechanics and knew the fights inside out. Avoided what needed avoiding and killed what needed killing. If I needed to tank, I popped heavy CDs to compensate for the low gear because the mobs were killed quickly.

ok I have an issue with this slightly.. if you are doing a raid.. you should not be spirit binding mage equip on a war or crafting equip on anything.. you aren't playing to your fullest and are making the raid more difficult for others... hence the vote kick would be justified.. you should not be allowed to equip or que up in crafting gear or dol gear... its just not fair to those giving the raid their all.. if you want to spiritbind gear that does not reflect your job you can easily do so in a beastmen camp... and not hold others back in a raid.. it is just good manners.

There was crafting rings, I was wearing the tanking gear apart from that.
[EDIT:] Again, I did rotate my offensive cooldowns and popped enough defensive cooldowns when needed to ensure my DPS was fine. I was still hitting 300-500+ depending on my buffs, if any. I kept the levi axe equipped so as not to totally gimp my DPS. You can still get players in higher gear who don't use cooldowns which will hold people back also. But yes, I will put my hand up and say I was holding back a bit because of my gear but not because of how I played. [/EDIT]

[Alistaire]

If he's meeting the item level for the dungeon upon entering, then you really have no right to kick him, especially if he's participating. If he changed his gear (thus lowering his ilvl) after joining, then sure, a kick is justified.

Not to get too far off topic, because I agree, if someone is kicked they should not be able to rejoin the same instanced ID. However it sounds like CT has some other issues on top of that. iLvl requirements and/or being allowed to change gear (that drops iLvl below the requirement) after joining.

I'd go a step further; if someone is kicked they should have the 30-minute lockout. And anyone saying "no because what if you're kicked unfairly", you already have your ability to report vote kick abuse in those cases. If a person is kicked justly they should be locked out; as it stands right now SE is only encouraging people to do things that will get them kicked in order to avoid leaving and getting the penalty.

[Macka]

I'd go a step further; if someone is kicked they should have the 30-minute lockout. And anyone saying "no because what if you're kicked unfairly", you already have your ability to report vote kick abuse in those cases. If a person is kicked justly they should be locked out; as it stands right now SE is only encouraging people to do things that will get them kicked in order to avoid leaving and getting the penalty.

So you saying a new player should eat a 30min penalty all because they got kicked for watching a cutscene. Ok, Kevin Hart leave the jokes for your show.