You don't necessarily need to match EVERYTHING to look great When you see someone looking stylish wearing trendy green pants (just an example) you DO NOT wear a green shirt, green shoes, green hair etc. it's nice to mix and match with complementary colors like browns or blues (in the case of green) in the case of your orange eyes... your orange hair may have been overkill. Why not compliment those lovely eyes with uhh... what's a nice color that compliments orange? Perhaps a dark blue or a dark green? maybe even go turquoise if you're in a daring mood!