Further proof that the market wards are a festival of failure.

[ObeiKinstar]

Can't we at least have the wards look like the alley, path, etc that we are running into? How come in Ul'dah I enter an alley and the magically POOF I'm in some strange place, doesn't make sense.

[Cairdeas]

Bayohne, I just dont understand. It is pretty crystal clear, that everyone ( the majority of players ) would prefer an auction house system for selling items

No we dont, We want a time saving and convenient way to sell our goods. Which you do not need an auction house for. The only reason you would need an Auction house is for Blind or Timed Bidding. Blind Bidding is easily manipulated by RMT's and breaks the economy easily, while Timed bidding is normally ignored as a feature in any "Auction House" Except by people who do not know the high side value of an item and want the most bang for their item.

As proofed by various threads. No one wants the bidding apparatus, they just want the time and Convenience and they can be implemented into the market wards.

[Anathiel]

And do you speak for the majority of players? Because as I recall on opening day of the game and dozens of game reviews was the lack of AH was a serious issue for the economy. And they said AH in particular. When the majority of people are saying they want an AH that's exactly what they want. I don't see how that's up to interpretation.

[Cairdeas]

And do you speak for the majority of players? Because as I recall on opening day of the game and dozens of game reviews was the lack of AH was a serious issue for the economy. And they said AH in particular. When the majority of people are saying they want an AH that's exactly what they want. I don't see how that's up to interpretation.

http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...-Auction-House

56 Respondants for Time and Convenience/non auctionhouse unique features vs 4 for actual bidding/unique auction house features.

[rainfish]

And do you speak for the majority of players? Because as I recall on opening day of the game and dozens of game reviews was the lack of AH was a serious issue for the economy. And they said AH in particular. When the majority of people are saying they want an AH that's exactly what they want. I don't see how that's up to interpretation.

The main failing of the game was it was just horrible to play, with further refinments the MW system would work just fine. The lack of an auction house is not why the game sucks and nobody plays it.

[Sorel]

And do you speak for the majority of players? Because as I recall on opening day of the game and dozens of game reviews was the lack of AH was a serious issue for the economy. And they said AH in particular. When the majority of people are saying they want an AH that's exactly what they want. I don't see how that's up to interpretation.

Actually, from various polls, the most votes from players were to make the Market Wards work better. Followed by replacing the Market Wards with an AH.

We can conduct the poll again, but the results will likely be the same as the previous polls.

[Viridiana]

And do you speak for the majority of players? Because as I recall on opening day of the game and dozens of game reviews was the lack of AH was a serious issue for the economy. And they said AH in particular. When the majority of people are saying they want an AH that's exactly what they want. I don't see how that's up to interpretation.

The problem being that many people seem to think "instant buying from an interface with some sort of delivery" is synonymous with "AH". An *auction* house would be a place with. . . y'know, *auctions*. I can't speak for XI's AH system, having never played it, but I know in WoW most items on their AH were bought out, not bid on. Only time most people would bid is if they really wanted something but couldn't afford/weren't willing to pay the buyout cost. As much as everyone loves to bash WoW around here, I'm sure a similar system would result in the same behavior here.

[Cairdeas]

The problem being that many people seem to think "instant buying from an interface with some sort of delivery" is synonymous with "AH". An *auction* house would be a place with. . . y'know, *auctions*. I can't speak for XI's AH system, having never played it, but I know in WoW most items on their AH were bought out, not bid on. Only time most people would bid is if they really wanted something but couldn't afford/weren't willing to pay the buyout cost. As much as everyone loves to bash WoW around here, I'm sure a similar system would result in the same behavior here.

Which would make such a system useless.

I'd rather see the Amazon model implemented which is essentially what the MW's are, but it just needs more tweak and fixes to get it right.

[Roughgalaxy]

Why not have a single npc retainer in each section that the players gives things to, to sell? add price history like in XI and I think that would clear up the congestion, and make it much easier to find what people are looking for.

[Cairdeas]

Why not have a single npc retainer in each section that the players gives things to, to sell? add price history like in XI and I think that would clear up the congestion, and make it much easier to find what people are looking for.

Price histories can be manipulated.