Vote Abandon has got to go

[Grailer]

Why cant they make it so if you click abandon you get booted if you don't you stay in the instance and wait for more party members... Wait that would be logical, cause some of us don't mind waiting 5 minutes rather than running something for 45 minutes all over again...

That would be the smart way to do it right

[FelisC]

It is abuse actually. I have seen this setup before in CT, and all you have to do is ask the alliance to trade a few ranged for a few melee. Cant tell me that the entire alliance was melee heavy, cause I have never seen that. Plus, in this case, the other 16 people are screwed as well, cause an entire group left.

It being possible to clear the instance with the party and voting to disband is not abuse; I don't see how you could say it is

[Squa]

Why cant they make it so if you click abandon you get booted if you don't you stay in the instance and wait for more party members... Wait that would be logical, cause some of us don't mind waiting 5 minutes rather than running something for 45 minutes all over again...

this, having other people in the group dictate you getting kicked out is silly, especially when 'replenish ranks' feature exists. I have to give SE a bad grade for this implementation.

[MurakumoMillennium]

I voted no in my party of 4 and healer still got booted. What's going on with that?

Vote kick ≠ vote abandon.

[Johnist]

While I disagree that is has to go all together, the 50% vote needed is BS. Should be at least a 75% or so majority. Basically two people can go together into a dungeon with the intent of kicking everyone just before the last boss and there's nothing that can be done about it.

For a 4-man party it takes a 75% vote (Initiator +2 so 3/4)
For a 8-man party it takes a 62.5% vote (Initiator +4 so 5/8)
For a 24-man Alliance I think it should take Initiator +12 or 54.17%

That is my opinion.

[BrandoH]

Short and sweet cuz I'm very angry right now: was in CT, Alliance A had 4 melee dps. Wiped 3x on Atomos, we almost had it the 3rd time. Someone Vote Abandoned, I clicked no, the Vote went through and I was booted.

This sounds like the exact situation Vote Abandon was created for. What exactly are you crying about?

Had you guys have been smarter, you could have swapped one or two of those melee throughout the whole alliance and got the clear. Who said you have to tackle atomos in only your groups?

[NefGP]

They need to take it a step further and allow us to vote out other alliances.

Just had a ridiculous session of CT where Group C was trolling us on Atomos over and over by backing out of the fight as the rest of us went in to MPK us.


Reported all of them for harassment.

[Xaimera]

people are abusing this and its only been out one day :/.
been in some great titan ex df parties where we reached and killed heart, thats pretty decent if we kept on going im sure we'd get closer and closer to winning.
but of course after like 2 tries the whole party is kicked.
wasting my food seriously lol.

[Zfz]

People need to stop saying "you guys wanted it and now you complain once its implemented".

Because those who wanted it isn't necessarily the same people as those complaining now.

And I agree that those who voted No should stay for replacements.

[Raestloz]

Agreed that those that don't want to abandon should stay.

Although to be fair, people have gone "please kick me" since Vote Kick has been around.