Opinion on tanking design

[PiedPiper]

I'm not convinced this is that much a limit. Perfect dodge would fit an evasion tank very well. As it is we have turtle and blood, evasion is the only classic tank paradigm left. That said our current blood tank isn't that... bloody. Both classes have the same effective hp, and actually if you break it down over time, warrior can mitigate more damage from cool downs than paladin can (excluding hallowed ground) via cool downs (note this is not counting shield oath).

[Bigpurpleharness]

I'm not convinced this is that much a limit. Perfect dodge would fit an evasion tank very well. As it is we have turtle and blood, evasion is the only classic tank paradigm left. That said our current blood tank isn't that... bloody. Both classes have the same effective hp, and actually if you break it down over time, warrior can mitigate more damage from cool downs than paladin can (excluding hallowed ground) via cool downs (note this is not counting shield oath).

I do wish they would make WAR more "Blood". They'd need to make IB scale with incoming damage, and fix storm's path healing though. Also, Bloodbath should be increased or renamed Bloody Nose.

I think they should also remove the dmg reduction on IB and and make vengeance back to what it was (Assuming they allow bloodbath to function well, in which case vengeance and BB would be great paired together)

[Paikis]

They'd need to make IB scale with incoming damage

It already does. 20% damage reduction scales perfectly with incoming damage.

and fix storm's path healing though. Also, Bloodbath should be increased or renamed Bloody Nose.

Storm's Path isn't about the heal anymore, it is all about that debuff... though letting it heal a % of max HP would be better than the current system it isn't needed. Bloodbath is a very minor cooldown that can heal for a significant amount over its duration, but it doesn't really 'pop'.

I think they should also remove the dmg reduction on IB and and make vengeance back to what it was (Assuming they allow bloodbath to function well, in which case vengeance and BB would be great paired together)

So you want them to nerf WARs?