I'm not going to write a book and explain why I disagree with OP. I will say it's obvious this is your first MMO forum expirence. Or you would know that gear being too effective for the opposite objective "PVP, PVE" there is community outrage pretty much. PVP and PVE have completely different play styles for classes and when a player only does one or the other usually they are bad at the latter of the two, and neither want those to have the rewards for mastering the other without having completed that content.