Whats the best crafting class?

[Castillan]

Culinarian is of most use, as it provides the only sustainable consumable resource.
As a consequence, Botany and Fishing to provide for Culinarian

All others are near pointless in this game as it stands.

[Nahara]

All others are near pointless in this game as it stands.

I disagree. High Quality iLv70 gear like the Vanya, Gryphonskin and Heavy Darksteel equipment sells for quite a lot on my server.

[Tsunenori]

If you want to be able to provide for yourself and your alts, Weaving, Leatherworking and Blacksmithing will get you the largest spread of items across all the Disciples.

If all you're looking for is gil, there is no one answer. Diversification is the key to a healthy income, because anything that stands out enough to be considered lucrative is going to be hammered by the masses until it isn't.

[Castillan]

I disagree. High Quality iLv70 gear like the Vanya, Gryphonskin and Heavy Darksteel equipment sells for quite a lot on my server.

Actually sells, or is just priced high? On my server, that stuff is priced for 500K-1M, but who has that much money, other than other crafters or farmers? Thing is, if you're starting off with crafting now, it's going to be some 1-2 weeks to max any one craft (depending on available leves and money), and by the time you gear up your crafting class enough to be able to reliably punch out HQ 2-star gear, you'd have been better off simply buying ilvl90 artifact gear with myth tomes in all but a few cases. If you're looking to buy any of this stuff, you'd be better of saving up myth tomes for the amount of time you'd need to save up enough money to buy said HQ 2-star gear (unless you're farming like crazy). The way the crafting is at the moment, you're only catering to suckers, and or one-off customers, who will slowly dry up.

[Axidrain]

Actually sells, or is just priced high? On my server, that stuff is priced for 500K-1M, but who has that much money, other than other crafters or farmers? Thing is, if you're starting off with crafting now, it's going to be some 1-2 weeks to max any one craft (depending on available leves and money), and by the time you gear up your crafting class enough to be able to reliably punch out HQ 2-star gear, you'd have been better off simply buying ilvl90 artifact gear with myth tomes in all but a few cases. If you're looking to buy any of this stuff, you'd be better of saving up myth tomes for the amount of time you'd need to save up enough money to buy said HQ 2-star gear (unless you're farming like crazy). The way the crafting is at the moment, you're only catering to suckers, and or one-off customers, who will slowly dry up.

i bet materia prices on ur server are priced high too right? hint2