PLEASE stop telling summoners to use Ifrit!!!

[Spythe]

I'm not sure what counterpoint you're trying to make by pulling in your Titan parser.
If you've compared your raw numbers of Wind Blade 191~205 to Burning Strikes (sum of two attacks 205~220), that raw number just reaffirms what I've said for raw damage without any buffs or debuffs.
My point was that Ifrit potency is higher. That is a constant.

Ifrit has higher potency but does less damage(per attack but the same overall damage) because he is melee and effected by mobs armor.

still no, let's say ifrit hits 215 damage every 4 seconds (autoattack + burning strike), that's 3225 damage per minute + 10% monk debuff = 3547, 2 flaming crush and 1 crimson cyclone, (115 each x3 then add 10% = 379) 3926 damage per minute.

I believe DK adds about 13% damage on attacks. Once again I'm not sure until I test it, figured someone else would of tested it by now. Ifrit does his auto attack more than just when burning strikes goes off so your napkin math is a bit off. You also forgetting to add his stun and AOE. There damage is pretty similar when Ifrit is on Sic and Garuda is on Obey. I still stand by my play with whatever pet you want up until the coil, but once you're in the Coil. Garuda is hands down the best pet since sooo many bosses have unfriendly melee moves.

Once again the argument shouldn't be who does the best raw DPS but whatever Contagion is better than Enhanced Pet Abilities. I would say Contagion is better atm so use Garuda, I still use Ifrit when I feel like being lazy on easy content/non coil.