PLD is the better tank. It's a better tank for everything in the game. That's a fact. It's better at -tanking-. However, on content that you don't -need- all of that extra tanking ability, such as CM, Prae, Ifrit, AK, TWP, etc, Warrior is the superior choice because it can still tank anything those dungeons have to offer, while dealing more damage, thus making it faster. I've yet to see 1 PLD 2 Relic DPS 1 Healer kill Demon Wall before bees pop, yet I've done that on WAR numerous times, it's not fair to put all of the load on the DPS when you could be doing more damage yourself. Stop making excuses.