When you look at it like this how is Warrior a worse tank?

[CurlyBruce]

Since it's on a fixed rotation that titan does if you pop everything and wait for him to pull it off you can heal WAAAAY more than he hits you for.
With 5 wrath built, Internal Release, Bloodbath, Berserk active you pop unchained and infuriated. Easy to Macro this in and you can hit in between the cd's going off.
Hit Infuriate for 5 wrath and Inner beast. The inner beast will cure you for roughly 3.5k.

First, Titan does Mountain Buster twice before his rotation resets and his entire rotation only takes about a minute or so to go through so at most you'd have your cooldowns for one of the busters. Second, for Inner Beast to heal for "roughly 3.5k" you'd have to be pulling off 1167(1076 with Bloodbath) damage with it and the only way to get even close to that is for a crit to happen which you can't guarantee so you're survival is left to RNG.

[Terabyt3]

snip

Yeah you got a poitn there actually. the crit is important. I was thinking of IR being active.

The difference between the two is that one is a preemptive tank while the other is a reactive tank.

Muchly agree! From TGS Yoshi did say that WAR requires more active input to play (popping more cooldowns etc.) but could be more effective than a pld in many case during testing. At the minute i think a lot of comparisons are 1 dimentional and just the difference between pre emptive and reactive almost makes them uncomparable.

This is bordering on a civilized discussion! Someone quick! Flame us all!