Have any warriors tanked HM titan/coil?

[Kjersgaard]

So what we have here is a legitimate problem or are we ok with defined content we cannot tank?

[Amurica]

Do you feel that these disparities are so egregious that SE will patch them just for this fight? Or do you think gear levels will even things out?

[Eronn]

So what we have here is a legitimate problem or are we ok with defined content we cannot tank?

I am fine with content existing that requires a Paladin to main tank over Warrior, so long as there are adequate uses for a Warrior in the fight or there are fights that require a Warrior. Personally I am largely against homogenization, skill wise and encounter wise.

Do you feel that these disparities are so egregious that SE will patch them just for this fight? Or do you think gear levels will even things out?

I doubt it. We could probably use some tweaks overall, especially regarding the Wrath mechanic, but I think as more content comes in usefulness will balance itself.

[Kjersgaard]

Have you found end game content where a group says "we'd rather have a warrior for this run"?

[Xilrasis]

Have you found end game content where a group says "we'd rather have a warrior for this run"?

For an offtank? Yes.

For a main-tank? No.

[Delorean]

Warrior is harder to play which explains some of the problems people are having.

well, just remember that it isn't all just the warrior player

the worse your healers are, the worse a bonus to healing becomes

a good healer predicts incoming damage and heals it up as it comes in, while a bad one does whatever it is that they do.

So what we have here is a legitimate problem or are we ok with defined content we cannot tank?

well even without doing the content i think its pretty safe to assume we are okay for anything up to coil as long as we have decent gear (ak/dl/af+1), and coil is probably going to hurt too much without gear.

Do you feel that these disparities are so egregious that SE will patch them just for this fight? Or do you think gear levels will even things out?

Should they make a minor tweak such as healing on defiance and not wrath as well as buffing it some? undoubtedly

Will they? I wouldn't hold my breath.

But as long as you are providing Data that conflicts with their perception of the game and their vision of the Warrior job that suggests it is not everything that they wanted it to be, you can't say you didn't do anything or try to communicate with them.

[ventlus]

we did titan with our warrior tank and man was he getting hard, this is with full darklight light/relic/af+1. In bahamuts coil the first boss hit hard for paladin, for warrior i was like eeeeeek

as a healer lol

[Comfy]

Just did turn 4 with a warrior tank and it went pretty well.

[Baci]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDu56mEBOP0

Did Titan with nearly only AK Gear+some Darklight Ring/Earring/Necklace/Bracelet and Ifrit Axe.

[Kagato]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDu56mEBOP0

Did Titan with nearly only AK Gear+some Darklight Ring/Earring/Necklace/Bracelet and Ifrit Axe.

This proof pudding tastes delicious. I want their recipe!