Press and player reactions to the new XIV

[Renshi]

I dont know for you guys, but for me the new trailer, if i wasnt a FFXIV players, wouldnot inspired me at all. In two words : It S"/$

The voice acting sounds like amateur.

The music background....hmm not so good.

And the video doesnt show much.

Remember that it is the "First FINAL FANTASY XIV: A Realm Reborn Trailer" as Youmokon said. So expect more!

[Avirex]

SE aren't doing themselves any favours by releasing a CGI video. Their CGI-skills have never been questioned, so it doesn't really give people any reason to think the game has gotten better.

^100% We never once said that SE's CGI skills sucked and bad CGI was never a deal breaker with me when it came to playing a game. Show us actual gameplay. i'm not going to drag myself through hours of bad gameplay for a 30 sec CGI video of epic standing.

[Seif]

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/20...a-realm-reborn

Eurogamer seems to get it but the public isn't impressed:
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/20...?page=comments

[Arcell]

Kotaku managed to post an article and not mindlessly bash the game, thankfully some of the commenters there were trying to actually inform people of the state of things.

[Fear]

This is just the first of probably many small teasers, the real trailer (with game footage) will come out during Gamescon

[Xatsh]

FFXIV is known as the worst mmo ever made, SE is going to have to drop 10s of millions on advertising to change peoples minds.

Unfortunately no one cares about XIV except us who are playing it now, just ask a mmo player who is not playing XIV what would you rather play GW2 which is being called revolutionary and it has no sub fee, or XIV 2.0. I would put money on over 95% of them saying GW2.

That is the hurdle SE needs to get over, and it will cost them alot. Which is what makes me worry,even top notch in-game footage if it is really good will not be enough to change peoples minds. They need to spam XIV on every channel similar to how WoW advertises expansions.

As for the reviews several have been positive, but the communities on those sites still are considering this to be same game that launched.

[Arcell]

I'd have to disagree. A few really well done gameplay trailers would do a ton to help this game. This biggest complaint I've heard about 2.0 and the new trailer especially is that it's not gameplay footage so it doesn't tell people anything about it. If they put a lot of effort into a handful of outstanding gameplay trailers I think that would do far more to help the game than pretty much anything else.

Ad spots aren't going to save this game, word of mouth that it has truly changed from other players will.

[Amherst]

Unfortunately no one cares about XIV except us who are playing it now, just ask a mmo player who is not playing XIV what would you rather play GW2 which is being called revolutionary and it has no sub fee, or XIV 2.0. I would put money on over 95% of them saying GW2.

Don't worry, just give it a couple months after it releases and people will complain about GW2, leave en masse, then move onto the next big MMO acting like it's the messiah of gaming.

If SE wants this to work out for them they really do need to highlight that this is pretty much an entirely different game, and really get aggressive about attracting PS3 players. I don't think the "hurr durr vXIII/VII" crowd is anything to worry about considering they just spam their opinions on that on every single article regarding Square-Enix, at least.

[Dawiichan]

From what I've read on the IGN and mmorpg comments, the news got fairly good comments.

[Griss]

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/20...a-realm-reborn

Eurogamer seems to get it but the public isn't impressed:
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/20...?page=comments

Its pretty much the same story over on Destructoid