Rokien's new thread on Open World.

[Felis]

The finding and claimig is open world, only the battle itself is instanced.

edit: wrong thread

[Hulan]

It makes the world feel more alive seeing people in the open world actually fighting and watching linkshells/guilds fighting hard HNMs..you know, making a world feel alive, something people want?

I'm not going to take sides on this argument, mostly because I'm not entirely sure myself where I come down on the "instance" v. "open-world" argument myself yet. That being said, I see this point brought up again and again by people promoting open-world content. It sound great on paper, but in practice, I don't think it really works that way. I played FFXI a lot; starting at NA release and finally closing down my account when FFXIV was officially released because I couldn't see myself playing 2 MMOs at the same time. In all that time, I cannot once remember - by chance - running into someone fighting an HNM or other open world NM.

I often saw people fighting HNMs or open world NMs, but always when I had business with the same HNM or NM. For very valid design reasons, HNMs and other open-world content is invariably tucked away in the middle of nowhere, unlikely to be happened upon by other players. So in reality, quite often open world content does not, in fact, add "life" to the game for the average player. Because the average player is almost never going to interact with that content.

As I said, I'm not sure where I come down on the issue as a whole, but the "open-world content brings the world to life" argument doesn't seem to hold up to real-world implementation. You could say, "Well they know that it's 'out there' somewhere", but the same could easily be said about instanced content, for a vast majority of players, the difference is academic.

[Kona4me]

I remember yoshi saying in last interview that if you find a primal wondering in the open world, the fight with it will be instanced?

Does that mean people out of free company will not be able to watch the battle?

I would like to see a free company battle a primal sometimes .

[Jinko]

I remember yoshi saying in last interview that if you find a primal wondering in the open world, the fight with it will be instanced?

Does that mean people out of free company will not be able to watch the battle?

I would like to see a free company battle a primal sometimes .

I doubt its any different than the current Ifrit fight, you could easily experience this yourself.

[Elexia]

I remember yoshi saying in last interview that if you find a primal wondering in the open world, the fight with it will be instanced?

Does that mean people out of free company will not be able to watch the battle?

I would like to see a free company battle a primal sometimes .

Yep, unless it's Psuedo Instanced like Guildleves are. Otherwise it seems a lot of the community thinks:

I would like to see a free company battle a primal sometimes .

Makes no sense to allow in the game. >__>

[Babydoll]

Yep, unless it's Psuedo Instanced like Guildleves are. Otherwise it seems a lot of the community thinks:



Makes no sense to allow in the game. >__>

Psuedo Instanced wouldn't be so bad...but I wonder what happens if they wipe? Even if its 100% instanced and they wipe...lol will it randomly pop again or....o.O

[Airget]

Open world content revolves around a lot things. It makes the world feel more alive seeing people in the open world actually fighting and watching linkshells/guilds fighting hard HNMs..you know, making a world feel alive, something people want?

Throwing everything into a closed off area of the game doesn't make an MMO feel alive, this is exactly why GW2 isn't like GW1, they realized an instanced sandbox doesn't make an MMO.

I'm a pleasent world yes, but ina cuthroat MMO where people will do underhanded acts to make you fail this isn't the case The "in the open world actually fighting and watching linkshells/guilds fighting hard HNMs" turns into "in the open world actually fighting and watching linkshells/guilds kill one another and lag each other out so the one who has claim over the NM dies and they can begin to fight said NM"

Sure GMs might be able to do something about it but honestly speaking sometimes favoritism is dealt with in those situation. Perfect example was during thanksgiving was helping a friend camp a Morbol NM in the TOAU area and a japanese player was purposely drawing the morbol mobs to where we were resting, sleeping them and then logging out so that when they woke up they would aggro us. The reason why this worked is because the Morbols in question had a large radius is which they could roam so he was able to take a group of 5-6 and bring it to our location in an attempt to wipe us. We called a GM mentioned what happened and long story short they did nothing about it. So ya having things set in instances is just a lot less of a headache and you know it keeps PVE as PVE not PVPVEVP all to claim that NM.

[Rokien]

I'm a pleasent world yes, but ina cuthroat MMO where people will do underhanded acts to make you fail this isn't the case The "in the open world actually fighting and watching linkshells/guilds fighting hard HNMs" turns into "in the open world actually fighting and watching linkshells/guilds kill one another and lag each other out so the one who has claim over the NM dies and they can begin to fight said NM"

Sure GMs might be able to do something about it but honestly speaking sometimes favoritism is dealt with in those situation. Perfect example was during thanksgiving was helping a friend camp a Morbol NM in the TOAU area and a japanese player was purposely drawing the morbol mobs to where we were resting, sleeping them and then logging out so that when they woke up they would aggro us. The reason why this worked is because the Morbols in question had a large radius is which they could roam so he was able to take a group of 5-6 and bring it to our location in an attempt to wipe us. We called a GM mentioned what happened and long story short they did nothing about it. So ya having things set in instances is just a lot less of a headache and you know it keeps PVE as PVE not PVPVEVP all to claim that NM.

I know a perfect game for you, Vindictus. Heck, I have a level 60 on there, I can help ya out.

[Krausus]

I know a perfect game for you, Vindictus. Heck, I have a level 60 on there, I can help ya out.

hyperbole much?


how about this name some good MMOs that are truly open world that suffer from very little issues, or how about a successful MMO that is truly open world.

[Rokien]

hyperbole much?


how about this name some good MMOs that are truly open world that suffer from very little issues, or how about a successful MMO that is truly open world.

I don't know a mmo that is truly open world, sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo, ya.