I really hate these JP vs ENG VA comparisons, it's like two things can't exist at the same time.

I played the game in English, and in all honesty, a lot of the VAs did an excellent job. Are we really going to pretend there isn't talent in there?

Also, I can never understand the belief that somehow Japanese VAs will always be superior in comparison to other languages like English. If you're one to say this over and over again on various media I would critically examine why that is. In fact, I really appreciate how English varies its utilization of the language depending on where in the world you are. I don't hear any dialects being used at all in the Japanese VA, not to say they are required to do that, but I like the variety utilized in the English version. It gives you a sense of a larger world in my opinion.