Sure it's a good idea to remove the static light dot from the eyes?

[Iscah]

neither of these pics are natural light, these are both photoshoots with studio lights and manacured set design.

Sure, but the second photo seems shot with the intention of mimicking natural lighting – and this entire game effectively is a photoshoot or movie set with the power to place studio lights wherever they feel like it, even in configurations that would be impossible in real life.