She is awesome, just let her be and also it is a nice character, stop making problems where there is none... and I think it may be a more judgemental thing, which usually is a US thing, none offense to that.
She is awesome, just let her be and also it is a nice character, stop making problems where there is none... and I think it may be a more judgemental thing, which usually is a US thing, none offense to that.
So the part I don't get out of all this. Go look at the appreciation thread, you don't see anyone going in being all like "you're wrong she sucked!". Yet for reason people just can't leave a critizism thread alone without saying our subjective opinion is wrong.
If you like her good for you, I can respect that. I however did not enjoy her performance.
Go praise her in the appreciation thread. Trying to convince us here will just bring out pointless arguments.
Also, please stop lumping all critizism as hate comments just because there's a few bad apples in these threads.
What do you mean "no problem" ? Even the FR and DE dubs sound better. The EN dub is rock bottom, quality is trash and wuk lamat's the worst offender in the history of the game. The EN dub should be the one in most widespread use so SE has absolutely no excuses for why it's so bad and why a new character that's on the poster sounds so bad. And let's not start about their translations not being accurate and diverging from the source material in whichever way the translation team wants. At this point you're better off just playing the game in JP both voice and text and using google to translate for you.
yeah clearly they are all totally genuine lmao, imagine not being genuine on the internet
oh wait....
a good show of people not being genuine is the immediate scream to transphobia the second anyone dares say that the person has too manly of a voice or that they dont sound good, people immediately YELLED TRANSPHOBIA !!! ANTI TRANS !!! ANTI LBGTQIA!!
dont even pretend that all these people dont have biases
Last edited by Stormpeaks; 01-19-2024 at 04:55 AM.
That's the joys of opinions. You don't have to like it, but trying to make it sound like they're defending the voice work for the sake of it because you don't agree with their opinion is pretty scummy.
Like I said at the start of this thread, it's fine. Not the best, not the worst. Just fine. I've heard worse in this game (kobold kid) and outside of it (Chaos Wars).
Almost like theirs some people being transphobic on purpose? Legit the only time I've seen people call out transphobia on these threads it's because they're genuinely doing it to rile people up I'm not assuming if you didn't like her voice acting work that you in particular are aganist trans people, nor anyone else who's just disliked the voice, you do know People are also allowed to be defensive about these sorts of issues back, I don't know what you really expect people to say?
I'm sure theirs some people "pretending" to like the voice but I bet you theirs a lot more people who are making a big deal out of it because the VA is trans, when they normally wouldn't have cared, A lot of people only use peoples lifes and issues to create drama and annoy people which should be called out, A lot of people are going to be very vocal about standing up for these rights when they get called into question day after day, I'm sure you would be defensive if your rights were questioned often
I liked the voice & I support LGBTQ+ rights, I liked the voice for separate reasons though, as I genuinely thought the casting was well done, but I need to hear more of it before a proper judgement.
Last edited by Rithy255; 01-19-2024 at 09:00 AM.
So much mental gymnastics trying to get the VA fired.
Seriously, everyone needs to give this a rest. SE has chosen the VA they want to use for the role. They aren't going to change things last minute (and this is last minute when it comes to the timeline for developing a major expansion).
If you don't like the VA's work, then switch to another language or mute Voice in System configuration.
same vibe asSo much mental gymnastics trying to get the VA fired.
Seriously, everyone needs to give this a rest. SE has chosen the VA they want to use for the role. They aren't going to change things last minute (and this is last minute when it comes to the timeline for developing a major expansion).
If you don't like the VA's work, then switch to another language or mute Voice in System configuration.
"you dont like x, just quit the game and dont complain"
yikes lol
This example is ironic because Phil grandstanded in favor of Cleveland getting swapped and promptly threw a tantrum when people called out Samurai Jack and the Scottish dude.Thats very much a no no. I will forever be on the stance that a VAs country or rep shouldnt be the deciding factor for hiring VAs to voice characters. Its like saying Phil Lamar; a black dude shouldnt be voicing an ancient Japanese swordsman.
However this also doesnt deter from my other stance that the performance was fine. Which it is.
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.