*Spoilers* Anyone feel joining Emet would have been better

[EaraGrace]

I don't recall disputing that reliance solely on him would not work given the nature of the true cause of the Final Days. What I am disputing is calling it idiotic with the context of the information that they had.

And I’m disputing ignoring that scene. If you wish to argue the specifics then do so, but that scene did occur and thus we must consider it in these discussions, especially when discussing the events it portrays.

Do you mean that scene whereby in the French version he narrows his concession to getting them to Ultima Thule? I don't consider it adequate, sorry. And that is even if I were inclined to simply take their opinions over more tangible evidence of how they'd react.

First, unless you wish to proffer a more accurate translations this is what it comes out as as far as I can see.

I must nevertheless recognize in her a certain gift of matchmaker. it is not with our methods that a human being managed to set foot here

Not as clear as your saying it is. Lots of symbolism laced in that. And second, once again what did Venat gain from Sundering her world? Why would her judgment, with Emet agreeing, be incorrect?

And I'd like to see how the ancients would've reacted and adapted to this information in full. Again, the plot was written in such a way where they weren't allowed it.

I surely would’ve too, as would Venat. Unfortunately, circumstances made it impossible. Such is life.

So she clearly didn't think that lowly of her people's general emotional resilience.

That quote is from before Ktisis. You don’t think her judgement may change once the full truth was laid bear? And many =/ all. The world would be divided, and as Venat says this would lead to their destruction.

And once more, insisting there is a canon statement to the effect of what they would've done in receipt of the full context behind her concerns, when there isn't, doesn't make your argument any stronger in this respect.

I fail to see how we don’t have a canon statement on what they would’ve done. The game beats you over the head with the message that they would’ve broken. Would you need Ishikawa to say it to confirm that fact?