Thaliak's Favor is nice.

Triple Hook not so much ? maybe for ocean fishing ? but for the cost you can almost use 2 Double hook. (MIN/BOT +2/+3 only get a 100 GP scale ; FSH is +300 GP...)

I guess the spearfishing minigame is decent.
I wish they expended the spear options because there's still only the lv.61 in the game. They said they couldn't add more/give it stats because it would affect "values" ; yet they changed said values with the stat squish, and nope, they just don't care.
I guess they can still make specialized spear (ex : faster reload ; wider head ; stealthier miss width) just for the minigame.

Now complains about FSH compared to the others gatherers : Maybe it's time to rebrand it as a "limited job".

-still almost no use for fishes
-retainers still useless outside of 1 minion
-still no QoL for logs (usefull infos ; search ; items link ; tp from map ; flags) but maybe that's just me on this one
-leves rewards are a joke (MIN/BOT get dozens of crystals ; you get 3 baits you can buy from npcs ; not even scripts ones)
-desynth still moslty sands (and no longer HQ ; for shame !)