Honestly the bigger issue over weather or not fellowships should be expanded or if these types of advertisements should be allowed in party finder is if any of these players in the screenshots received black marks for this nonsense.

In an abysmally draconian system of "3 strikes and youre out with no questions", you get a black mark over this?!?!

This sets a extremely dangerous precedent as a symptom of years of inconsistent rule enforcement with the added fact that GMs in this game have a reputation moreso in any other game for being uncontrolled, whimsical, and contradictory is such a massive problem because these players are now stuck with a black mark FOREVER.

A GM like the one this entire thread is about playing fast and loose with the rules with absolutely no system in place for an appeals process should literally frighten everyone. It doesnt matter if you raid, craft, RP, whatever. The fact that you can be held to account eternally for anything a GM thinks youve done wrong is a hilarious situation that should be addressed immediately.