I personally can't fault him for that though, because there are a lot of melee-unfriendly fights in this game. To say otherwise is just being delusional.Mr Happy ticked off a lot of the early game's community with his Garuda EX guide, which basically said "If you want to clear, don't bring melee dps."
A good melee could get around the aspects that made Garuda EX trickier for melee, but ranged could just outright ignore those aspects. As a result, you were gambling less with a random PUG ranged than you were with a random PUG melee.