Quote Originally Posted by Ronduwil View Post
It won't be a surprise. That's why I said "well-designed." I cleared most of the Heroic raids in the WoW Cataclysm expansion. I'm very familiar with the "everyone needs to maximize their DPS and then some to beat the enrage timers" style of game design. I just think it's crappy. But I didn't think we were discussing high end content here. Maybe I misunderstood, but I thought we were talking about damage meters in the dungeon roulette, not end game raiding. If you're running end game raids with your guild, then of course criticism should be expected, embraced, and encouraged. If you're clearing bosses effortlessly with a bunch of sprouts in the dungeon roulette, however, you just come off like a jerk when you call someone out for under-performing.
And then they get to SB trials and lvl 80 dungeons and keep failing the DPS checks, wiping and failing mechanics because no one called them out for them to clean up their act. They'll carry on blissfully thinking everything's fine.