Quote Originally Posted by Maeka View Post
With these new rules, I could have you banned (or try to) just because you assumed I had a gender. What if I identify as an asexual snail? I could, in all honesty, report you for hurting my feelings by implying I have a gender.

(Obviously I wouldn't do that, but with the way the rules are worded? That is very much a possibility)
Not if I report you first for offending me about you not having a gender. (Which I wouldn't do at all, but the rules state I can).

Which brings up a point, "whoever reports first, wins."

Example: party in a dungeon, fully pugged. PLD tank asks if it is ok to do big pulls and gives his opinion on why they should. The healer and one DPS say yes. The other DPS says no and gives their own opinion. The group states they will pull big anyway, rejecting the non-big pull DPS's opnion. The healer feels belittled by the opinion of the rejecting DPS. Both the healer and the rejecting DPS will report. The rejecting DPS will report for not having their opinion considered and it causing some exclusion. The healer will report the rejecting DPS for belittlement.

Who gets disciplined can be based on who is reports first. If the rejected DPS gets reported first by the healer, the GM could take action against the DPS but not the rest of the group for their "infraction." If the DPS reports first, the GM could discipline the whole group, but not address the belittlement by the rejecting DPS.